Welcoming Little Sprouts Dental Families to Teeth & Co.
Growing together to serve Cedarburg with care for every stage of life.
We are proud to welcome the families of Little Sprouts Dental to Teeth & Co. in Cedarburg. By coming together, we are expanding the care we provide and making it easier for families to receive children’s and family dentistry all under one roof.
As part of this transition, Dr. Matthew Bernard has stepped away from practicing due to health challenges, but his legacy of warm, patient-centered care for children will live on at Teeth & Co.
Our practice is led by Dr. Amy Shay and Dr. Neal Rosenberg, who share a commitment to compassionate, high-quality care for every patient. Dr. Shay brings over ten years of experience working with a focus on children’s dentistry and is dedicated to creating positive dental experiences for kids. Together, Dr. Shay and Dr. Rosenberg provide trusted care for the entire family, supported by a team that is proud to serve the Cedarburg community.
What this means for Little Sprouts families:
- The same friendly faces you know will continue your care.
- Care is temporarily provided at our two convenient Cedarburg locations until renovations at the St John St. location is complete.
- We offer expanded services for every stage of life, from children to adults.
We are honored to carry forward the spirit of Little Sprouts Dental and look forward to welcoming your family into the Teeth & Co. family. If you have any questions or concerns or want to schedule your next appointment, call 262-297-0079 or by clicking the link below.
Meet our Doctors
Dr. Amy Shay
Dr. Shay is a native of Winona, MN, and a life-long packer fan, despite her Minnesotan roots! She graduated from the University of St. Thomas with a degree in Biology, and is a dental graduate of Marquette University School of Dentistry. Having met her husband during dental school, they decided to settle down in Wisconsin, and love living in charming Cedarburg!
Practice philosophy:
Building personal, trust-filled, fun relationships with her patients is Dr. Shay’s highest joy, and years spent practicing with children dentistry in community health confirmed for her what a huge difference a confident smile can make! Her collaborative approach to oral health, with attention to wellness and comfort, helps Dr. Shay tailor her care plans to the goals of her patients. Understanding those goals, and supporting them with gentle care and applicable education, leads Dr. Shay to meaningful, lasting relationships that transcend the dental chair.
Life outside of work:
Dr. Shay can usually be found wrangling any one of her four children alongside her husband, Dan. Playing good music while cooking, reading a book while sipping a warm beverage, and just soaking up a quiet moment on her front porch are all things that bring her peace and joy! In her free time, she loves yoga, quality time with her husband or friends, and browsing the local
shops for fun antiques!
Dr. Neal Rosenberg
Dr. Neal Rosenberg grew up in Grafton, WI, went to UW-Milwaukee for undergrad and masters (in chemistry) and Marquette University for Dentistry in 2014. He then spent a year in Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery at St Johns Providence in Detroit and received his Fellowship in the Academy of General Dentistry in 2022.
Dr. Neal Rosenberg has been practicing dentistry in the area since 2015, and brings unique training in the field of surgery and dental implant placement along with a wide array of services to our wonderful patients.
When he is not creating beautiful smiles, he loves to hunt, fish, work on his martial arts, and spend time with wife and two small children.
Visit our two locations!
5009 Columbia Rd, Cedarburg, WI
N57W6296 Center St., Cedarburg, WI,
Hours that fit your schedule
We make it easy on you to schedule your appointment around your always busy life.
Flexible Insurance & Payment Plans
We know not everyone has the same insurance. To ensure smooth process all around, we work with a variety of plans and providers.
Wide array of Oral Health Services
We want to be the only place you have to visit for your oral health needs. That's why we offer a wider variety of services than most dentists
Highly Skilled & Trained Team
Our highly qualified and experienced team can handle any questions you may have regarding your oral health.
No Dental Insurance? No Worries!
If you don’t carry or prefer to avoid insurance companies and the headaches that come with them, Teeth & Co. offers our Dental Health Savings Club plans, to help bring peace of mind to you!
For the same price to get your car waxed and shined each month, you can enjoy peace of mind about your oral health. Monthly plans are available for both groups and individuals! A Dental Savings Club membership will both save you on your preventive dental costs and prevent future dental headaches, all at a price significantly less than traditional dental insurance.
Dental Health Savings Club Membership Plans
Children (Ages 13 and Under)
$16.50 Monthly($41.66 due at signing)*
Adults (Ages 14+)
$25 Monthly($50 due at signing)*
*Initial payment includes $25 setup fee. Payments deducted from a credit/debit card. No cash payment.
MEMBERSHIP INCLUDES:
- Full mouth series of dental x-rays — This is a “big picture” view taken once every 3 years to check for cancer, cavities, infections in the jaw bones, and gums.
- Bitewing dental x-rays — This quick snapshot is taken once a year to check for small cavities and early onset of gum and bone disease.
- Two preventative cleanings or periodontal maintenance per year* — Work with our dental hygiene team to take those pesky stains off your teeth and remove any calculus and tartar. Our dental hygiene team will also work with you to develop your custom home care plan to keep your teeth sparkling and white between visits.
- Two periodic dentist exams per year — At your preventative cleaning, our team will check out your smile to make sure you’re cavity free and that your gums and bone are healthy. We’ll also complete an oral cancer screening every time.
- Two fluoride varnish applications — When applied twice a year or more, fluoride varnishes can prevent cavities in kids and adults! Traditional dental insurance stops covering these at about 16 years old, but here at Teeth & Co., we want you to be healthy and use them for a lifetime.
PLUS EXCLUSIVE SPECIAL OFFERS AND DISCOUNTS!
- $100 off of teeth whitening — Select either our lifetime custom tray or our express whitening option!
- $300 off Invisalign orthodontic treatments
- 15% off any treatments not covered by the plan
- No waiting periods, no maximums, and no deductibles — EVER!
*Additional cleanings and perio maintenance are paid at a discount.
Terms and Conditions
One time setup fee of $25.
$25/month for the duration of the contract for adults.
$16.50/month for the duration of the contract for children 13/younger.
Patients must sign up for an automatically renewing contract. You must remain in the plan and pay membership fees for a minimum of 12 months.
Payment of less than 12 months’ membership fees may result in being charged usual and customary fees for all services (including those already provided) and being charged remaining months’ fees in lump sum.
Patients must stay the duration of the contract but can discontinue on their plan anniversary upon written notice to the practice.
Fees for dental services are due as services are rendered.
Fees for prosthodontics and cast restoration services are due at the preparation/impression visit. Failure to comply may result in my being charged usual and customary fees for such services.
Minor Services are defined as any direct composite or alloy restorations as defined by Current Dental Terminology [CDT] codes D2110-D2394. Major services include but are not limited to any other CDT codes including crowns, fixed partial dentures, extractions, dental implants, orthodontics.
You must agree to pay any and all costs in collecting all charges. Including but not limited to attorney fees and court costs. Coverage must be continuous. Missing monthly payments must be made up for interrupted coverage. Last month fees are not refundable.
DENTAL LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS
1) Demonstrated non-compliance with recommended course of treatment.
2) Services which in the opinion of the attending dentist are neither necessary nor recommended for the patient’s dental health.
3) Dispensing of drugs not normally supplied in a dental office.
4) Services for injuries or conditions which are covered under Worker’s Compensation or Employer’s Liability laws.
5) General anesthesia/Conscious Sedation
6) Services that cannot be performed because of the general health, physical or psychological limitations of the patient.
7) Plan Participants cannot have other dental coverage.
Sign up for our very own patient portal powered by Acrew
At Teeth & Co. we want you to feel empowered about all your oral health care choices. That is why we are providing you with your own patient portal. You can now manage multiple items for you and your family including:
- Paying your bills
- Scheduling your appointments
- Updating your health forms
- And more!
Your own portal is the next step in providing high quality care for all our patients, giving you the convenience to manage your oral healthcare, in the palm of your hand.
Dental care for the way you live. Click below to find out everything you’ll need to know.